Posted by
Dr. Ray Usell on Thursday, October 02, 2008 6:44:17 PM
Taxes are made complex so you won’t understand them. If you understood, you would fire the politicians that make them. Here is a test: How much goes to the Federal government related to a $100 purchase you make, $10, $20, $30? If you are a middle class taxpayer, the answer is $50-$60. Since you probably find this hard to believe (as I did), I show details below.
I calculate the Federal burden on you and people like you, not rich people. I use taxable incomes from almost zero to levels well within the middle class. The result shows the Federal government has a major impact on everyday life. In a sense, it places a $50-$60 drag on your $100 decisions. The Federal government is just too big. Its size and power have attracted greedy corrupt power hungry people. It causes big problems and it’s intrusions into the economy eventually make things worse.
The overall lesson is simple – vote for people that want to shrink Federal government; vote against those that want to grow it.
Here is the setting. It’s year-end, when people do a lot of discretionary spending. You buy a present for someone with a price tag of exactly $100. It was made in America out of components made in America and by American labor. You bought directly from the manufacturer. The question: what is the total Federal “take” from you and those that should benefit from the purchase?
Here is the breakdown of the Federal “take” related to a $100 purchase. The meaning of each line is explained below the table.
Marginal income tax rate (defined below) 15% 10%
Your income related taxes $43.37 $33.87
Manufacturer’s corporate tax $ 4.31 $ 4.31
Shareholder income tax $ 0.60 $ 0.40
Laborer’s income related taxes $13.28 $11.09
Component manufacturers corp. tax $ 1.89 $ 1.89
Total Federal “take” $63.45 $51.56
Here are the details behind the above numbers. Grinding through this may be the only way to be convinced. Each step is simple. The assumptions are straight forward and reasonable.
First is how much extra must you earn to have $100 after paying Federal Income & FICA taxes?
This is where the “end of the year” aspect comes in. Your “marginal tax rate” is the percent you pay on the last money earned in a year. I’ll show the details for people in the 15% bracket believed to cover most readers of the blog. If you are single and your taxable income is between $8K (K = thousand) and $32K, your marginal rate is 15%. (Below $8K, it is 10%.) For a couple, the range is $16K to $64K. (Below $16K, it is 10%.) The above table covers a very large portion of the middle class.
FICA adds another 15.3% (half paid by an employer or all by the self-employed), for a total of 30.3%. You must earn $143.47 to cover Federal taxes and leave $100 for a purchase. That is, 0.303 X $143.47 = $43.47, the tax, leaving $100 for the purchase.
Second is how much Federal Corporate tax did the item manufacturer pay related to the $100 sale?
If the manufacturer profits 8% ($8.00) on the sale after it pays its 35% Federal Corporate tax, it had to have $12.31 of “before-tax profit”. The manufacturer paid $4.31 in Corporate tax. That is, 0.35 X $12.31 = $4.31. (Note, the effective Corporate tax rate on sales is 4.31% under my 8% after-tax profit assumption. We use this number below.)
We must make a few more assumptions about the manufacturer and others involved:
1) The manufacturer pays half its $8.00 profit to shareholders, who also are in the 15% bracket. (The rest is retained for new product research or whatever.)
2) Manufacturing cost ($100 – $12.31 = $87.69) is evenly split between labor cost and purchased components.
3) The laborers are in the 15% income tax bracket.
4) The component manufacturers all have an 8% after tax profit structure.
The shareholders of the manufacturer will pay income tax, 15% of $4.00 is $0.60.
The laborers will pay 15% income tax and, together with the manufacturer, another 15.3% FICA. The total Federal “take” for labor is 0.303 X $43.84 = $13.28.
The component manufacturers will pay $1.89 in Federal Corporate tax. That is 0.0431 X $43.84 = $1.89.
The Federal Income Tax rates can be found at:
http://www.irs.gov/formspubs/article/0,,id=164272,00.html
The IRS site has links to all the rates used above.